Breakingfree! Awesome post. Don't EVER apologize for posting your thoughts. This is a support community, our quit family. There is nothing like a great discussion to wake everyone up.
All that being said, and being a quitter that is over 300 days, I want to say that I disagree with you. Prior to this quit the longest I had ever quit was four days. As Rusty said the emotional aspect of this quit is the hardest. In part I do agree with the thought process that you posted. What I disagree with is the actual physical crave.
For ME, in the beginning the craves make me feel I would go totally insane, seemed to be never ending, and were a physical NEED. Further into the quit, the craves are more like a strong desire. That wanting a cigarette is like wanting to take a cruise to Alaska. Do I need a cigarette or a trip to Alaska? No I do not. Do I want it sometimes, yes I do.
There is no way I would ever intentionally give up my quit however, there have been times that I have needed help saving me from myself. There have been times that I almost bought cigarettes or asked someone for a cigarette later in my quit. If I am totally honest, there was an instant just a few weeks ago when I was frustrated that I actually asked one of my old smoking buddies for a cigarette. Did I want it? Did I crave it? Yes, I did. More than anything at the time. He didn't give me one. Thank God because if he had of, I would have smoked it.
I believe our addictive thinking is still with us long after we quit the physical act of smoking. When some things happen, our addictive minds immediately start thinking that the cigarette will somehow allow us some magical release, a safe haven to hide in if you will. This feeling is very real and to me it is a crave. Most importantly, if we don't reach out for help in times of need we risk losing our quits.
A lot of older quiters do not post about craves because they don't want to discourage newbies. I have heard this from older quitters time and time again. I think whether we are on day 3 or day 363.. if we feel a need to reach out to this support community to keep our quits, we should feel free to do so. The last thing any long term quitter wants to do is discourage a new quitter from experiencing the freed