Hi oldblue
Are you Canadian? I've heard that apologizing all the time is a Canadian trait :) Someone steps on my toe or bumps into me and I apologize. I didn't even realize I did it until it was pointed out to me, and I don't think I did it because I actually felt sorry -- it was just something to say. Since my depression, I do apologize more and with feeling ("I'm sorry -- I should have anticipated that you were coming into this space and got out of your way before you had to bump into me and step on my toe" sort of thing), and I'm working on overcoming the belief that everyone else is worthier and more important than I am.
I do wonder, though, whether or not my habit of apology doesn't create a bit of a spiral in itself. If I toss off an "oh, sorry" for no reason except as something to say, I hear myself say it now and beat myself up for being wimpy, which then erodes my self-esteem further, if that makes any sense.
Either way, I hear you, oldblue. I'm curious -- do you only over-apologize in your relationship or is it more widespread as it is for me? Catching myself and biting my tongue before I apologize has been something I've been practicing for awhile now, and I'm getting better at it I'm pleased to say :)
I agree with you about emotions -- I think there are positive and negative ones. I don't think that there are right or wrong emotions, though. Emotions just are... we feel them and they're not right or wrong -- it's the behaviours we choose to use to express our emotions that can be right or wrong, I believe, as well as positive and negative. To have both you and your boyfriend monitoring your moods sounds a bit onerous -- no wonder you're sick of it.
Okay, here's a question: is it wrong or unhelpful in the long run to lie and say you're feeling reasonably good? I do this because I'm also sick of feeling down, and I sometimes even believe myself, but are there downsides to it? I think I must have been an ostrich in an earlier life because there are times when I really do believe that when I bury my head in the sand my problems cease to exist.
Granted, the "lie" word is a tricky one in an open and honest relationship, so what if your response to his "how are you feeling" was, every once in a while, "I love you for asking but I don'